Vladimir Putin has created his own worst nightmare

Obtain free Vladimir Putin updates

Fifteen months in the past, Vladimir Putin’s military was on the outskirts of Kyiv. Now the Russian chief is struggling to take care of management in Moscow.

The rise up of Wagner forces, led by Yevgeny Prigozhin, is the ultimate affirmation of how catastrophically incorrect the struggle in Ukraine has gone for Putin. Even when the Russian chief prevails within the speedy battle in opposition to Wagner, it’s arduous to consider that Putin can in the end survive this type of humiliation. His status, his energy, even his life, at the moment are on the road.

The historic irony is that Putin’s personal actions have introduced in regards to the factor he fears most: an revolt that threatens each the Russian state and his personal private energy.

Putin’s worry of a “color revolution” in Russia dates again virtually 20 years. Fittingly, its origins lie in Ukraine. The Orange revolution of 2004 — a preferred, democratic rebellion in opposition to a rigged election in Ukraine — sparked a paranoia within the Russian president that has steadily intensified through the years.

Ever since, Putin has been haunted by two linked fears. First, that Ukraine would slip irrevocably from Russia’s grasp. Second, {that a} profitable pro-democracy rebellion in Kyiv can be a dry run for a similar factor in Moscow.

His resolution to invade Ukraine in 2022 was an effort to lastly snuff out each risks — by putting in a pro-Russian, authoritarian authorities in Kyiv.

As a former intelligence operative and conspiracy theorist, Putin was satisfied that the origins of any “color revolution” — whether or not in Ukraine or Russia — would lie in Washington. His refusal to consider that Ukrainians may need company or energy led to his deadly underestimation of the power of the nation’s resistance to a Russian invasion.

In addition to underestimating Ukrainian power, Putin — drunk on the mythology of the Pink Military of the Nineteen Forties — fatally overestimated Russia’s personal navy energy. The failure of the Russian military opened the door for the Wagner group to enter the struggle. This gave Prigozhin his personal energy base and propaganda platform and in the end allowed him to activate the Russian state.

Putin’s pitch to the Russian individuals has at all times been that he rescued the nation from the anarchy of the Nineties. However what is occurring now could be harking back to the failed navy and hardliner coup in opposition to Mikhail Gorbachev in 1991, when Boris Yeltsin mounted a tank outdoors parliament. At that time, the individuals of Moscow performed a significant function within the unfolding occasions. The response of the Russian inhabitants to the Prigozhin rebellion will likely be an important — and, as but, unknown — a part of this story.

In his personal first remarks on the Prigozhin rebellion, Putin seemed again to an excellent darker precedent: the alleged “stab within the again” that ended the Russian struggle effort in 1917 and pitched the nation into revolution and civil struggle. These phrases have been meant to convey firmness of objective. However they have been hardly reassuring.

The Wagner revolt will give hope to opponents of the Putin regime — each inside and outdoors Russia. For the Ukrainian navy, whose counter-offensive has failed to interrupt by means of, this seems like a historic alternative. If Russia’s forces activate one another, or are pulled again from the frontline to defend Putin, they might fold in japanese Ukraine.

Political prisoners in Russia, akin to Alexei Navalny or Vladimir Kara-Murza, should even have a brand new sense of hope and alternative. They, too, might play a component over the approaching months.

Prigozhin, in fact, isn’t any liberal. His rhetoric is stridently nationalist and imperialist. The Wagner forces have a well-earned status for brutality. However Prigozhin — like Putin — has now unleashed forces that he’ll wrestle to manage.

gideon.rachman@ft.com