Overhaul of courts in England and Wales beset by problems, say MPs

Obtain free UK politics & coverage updates

Issues with a £1.3bn authorities programme to modernise the courts in England and Wales have positioned an “unacceptable” burden on the justice system, MPs have warned, as figures present a document variety of critical prison instances are taking greater than two years to conclude.

The Home of Commons public accounts committee stated in a report printed on Friday that it was “severely involved” about long-delayed reforms of the courts geared toward making the justice system extra accessible and environment friendly.

Sweeping adjustments, a few of which have been applied, embody digital courtroom hearings, on-line portals for divorce and probate functions, and digital case data.

HM Courts and Tribunals Service, the federal government company answerable for implementation, had initially deliberate to finish them inside 4 years however is now seven years in, in keeping with the report.

In March officers prolonged the timetable for a 3rd time and now suggest to ship a lot of the adjustments by subsequent March, though they don’t anticipate to completely roll out a digital “case administration” platform till 2025, stated the committee.

The report discovered the platform had been beset by “technical and performance points” that had “positioned an unacceptable extra burden on the courts”.

“We’re severely involved that, regardless of a protracted historical past of resets to the programme, HMCTS has needed to revise and delay its plans once more,” stated the MPs.

In the meantime, attorneys have warned {that a} case backlog is leaving victims and defendants ready a very long time for trials to conclude.

Official information launched on Thursday confirmed that, as of the primary quarter of this 12 months, about 17,300 excellent instances in crown courts — which take care of critical prison offences together with homicide, rape and theft — had been open for a 12 months or extra, equal to 29 per cent of the overall.

Of those, greater than 6,000 — or 10 per cent — had been nonetheless excellent after two years. This compares with solely about 500, or 1 per cent, in the identical interval in 2014.

“The backlogs now confronted pose an actual risk to well timed entry to justice,” stated Meg Hillier, Labour chair of the general public accounts committee.

Whereas the courts had been “crying out” for reform, the committee’s report discovered HMCTS was “now speeding to introduce its [reform] plans following a number of delays”, she added.

Lubna Shuja: ‘Reform is lengthy overdue however mustn’t be achieved in a approach that provides to the burden on judges, courtroom employees, solicitors and barristers’ © Darren Filkins/Regulation Society

Legal professionals stated they shared the issues. Lubna Shuja, president of the Regulation Society, which represents solicitors, stated: “Reform is lengthy overdue however mustn’t be achieved in a approach that provides to the burden on judges, courtroom employees, solicitors and barristers who’re already overstretched.”

The MPs stated that, of its £1.3bn reform funds, HMCTS had solely £120mn remaining to ship remaining adjustments.

They expressed concern the company had “moved some initiatives out of the [reform] programme into its business-as-usual actions”.

HMCTS had “burnt by means of nearly its total funds for a programme of reform solely a bit over midway full”, stated Hillier.

The MPs’ findings follows a report into the identical reforms by the Nationwide Audit Workplace, parliament’s spending watchdog, in February.

The NAO discovered the best issues had been with the case administration system for prison courts, whose design was “beset with issues” and implementation was “having a detrimental influence”. Nonetheless, it stated the system had “undoubtedly improved since its preliminary rollout”.

The Ministry of Justice stated: “We’re modernising our courts so they’re match for the twenty first century and the digital companies we’ve launched have been used efficiently over 2mn instances.”

A spokesperson stated: “The variety of excellent instances within the Crown Courtroom stays decrease than when the barristers’ strikes ended final 12 months and the system is working at full capability, with limitless sitting days and extra judges being recruited to revive the swift entry to justice victims deserve.” 

Back To Top